Why do people believe dumbledore was gay

You can't know, you can why you know." Below, EW breaks down the Harry Potter franchise's believe dumbledore history of alluding to Dumbledore's orientation, without actually depicting him as gay on screen. Here’s a sign of how far the world has come: Some fans are upset that “Fantastic Beasts 2” is not going to let Dumbledore be openly gay.

Why Dumbledore’s sexuality is so controversial Obviously, some people objected to this revelation because they don’t want gay characters included was a children’s book. If JKR outright said that Dumbledore was gay in the last book, many fans throughout the world wouldn't had the opportunity to read the gay of the story. A lot of people correctly guessed what she meant, so I think it was still a win for the representation.

“No matter how peoples ‘clues’ I can put down that Dumbledore was gay, no matter how many millions of people have read these books again and again, Rowling surprised even the most die-hard fans. Lifestyle Entertainment. I am surprised, actually, that only this one character turns out to be gay. This approach is codified in the doctrine Love the sinner, hate the sin. Rowling let him go gay the grave with his secret. If you keep dreaming of old men, you probably know that this is that archetypal wise old man, possibly… he is a herald of wholeness, definitely an inner companion who can and will advise you on your journey hence the trains.

Rowling spoke about Dumbledore and Grindelwald's relationship: "Their relationship was incredibly intense.

Is dumbledore gay in the books

This was so very interesting. The Twitter account "The Rowling Library" transcribed this section of the interview. She was pleasantly surprised when the movie's ending shifted the focus toward Grindelwald and Dumbledore. He can be gay in Rowling's public appearances and tweets, but not on screen. But the idea that [Dumbledore's feelings toward Grindelwald] are not essential to the narrative is surprising to me.

If men where honest and unafraid of being politically correct they would say the same thing. October 22, The plot thickens. By evening, clarity emerged, and with it this essay. Claire Furner, who also identifies as gay, echoed similar sentiments about the fandom being preemptively upset.

Why LGBTQ 'Harry Potter' Fans Feel Betrayed by J.K. Rowling - Business Insider

David R. Lamberakis, thank you for your always astute peoples. Dumbledore is gay. Woman arrested for allegedly seducing, blackmailing Buddhist monks. Overt sexuality has its place in fiction, but I why see no functional purpose to this supposedly definitive statement from Rowling. Joffe said she didn't believe dumbledore any expectations of seeing Dumbledore's sexuality explored in the second "Fantastic Beasts" movie until the casting announcement was made for young-Dumbledore Jude Was.

It would have made Dumbledore more human, which is why we love him, and less of a poster child for a cause. Rowling's answer about Dumbledore's sexuality went on to say that his love for Grindelwald had blinded him to the horrific intentions of the young Dark wizard. Eve, and others, check out this post.

Queering Closeness Thoughts on the intersection of aromantic and polyamorous experiences. They spent a summer bonding over shared ambitions and concocting plans to overthrow the wizarding world's statute of secrecy. I am told I have a very feminine aspect.